Related trials
ENGAGE-AF TIMI 48 High dose, 2013 - edoxaban vs warfarin standard dose
ARISTOTLE, 2011 - apixaban vs warfarin standard dose
AVERROES, 2011 - apixaban vs aspirin
ROCKET-AF, 2010 - rivaroxaban vs warfarin standard dose
ACTIVE A, 2009 - aspirin + clopidogrel vs aspirin
RE-LY (150mg), 2009 - dabigatran 150mg vs warfarin standard dose
RE-LY (110mg), 2009 - dabigatran 110mg vs warfarin standard dose
Lip (phase 2 AZD0837), 2009 - AZD0837 vs warfarin standard dose
AMADEUS, 2008 - idraparinux vs warfarin standard dose
PETRO (150mg), 2007 - dabigatran 150mg vs warfarin standard dose
ACTIVE W, 2006 - aspirin + clopidogrel vs anticoagulant
Japanese AF Trial, 2006 - aspirin vs control
SPORTIF V, 2005 - ximelagatran vs warfarin standard dose
NASPEAF (triflusal + coumadin medium dose vs coumadin standard dose), 2004 - triflusal+coumadin medium dose vs coumadin standard dose
NASPEAF (triflusal+coumadin medium dose vs triflusal), 2004 - triflusal+coumadin medium dose vs triflusal
NASPEAF (triflusal vs coumadin standard dose)), 2004 - triflusal vs coumadin standard dose
SAFT(warfarin low dose + aspirin vs no treatment), 2003 - warfarin low dose + aspirin vs control
SPORTIF III, 2003 - ximelagatran vs warfarin standard dose
SPORTIF II (ximelagatran vs warfarin standard dose), 2002 - ximelagatran vs warfarin standard dose
PATAF (coumadin low dose vs coumadin standard dose), 1999 - coumadin low dose vs coumadin standard dose
PATAF (vs coumadin standard dose), 1999 - aspirin vs coumadin standard dose
LASAF(aspirin vs no treatment), 1999 - aspirin vs control
PATAF (vs coumadin low dose), 1999 - aspirin vs coumadin low dose
AFASAK II (aspirin vs warfarin low dose), 1998 - aspirin vs warfarin low dose
AFASAK II (warfarin low dose+aspirin vs warfarin standard dose), 1998 - warfarin + aspirin vs warfarin standard dose
See also:
All atrial fibrillation clinical trials
All clinical trials of direct factor Xa inhibitors
All clinical trials of apixaban
|
|
Treatments
Studied treatment |
apixaban 5 mg (or 2.5 mg) twice daily
|
Control treatment |
aspirin 81-324 md daily
|
Patients
Patients |
patients with atrial fibrillation who have failed or are unsuitable for vitamin K antagonist treatment |
Inclusion criteria |
atrial fibrillation and at least one high-risk factor (prior stroke or transient ischemic attack, an age of 75 years or older, arterial hypertension (receiving treatment), diabetes mellitus (receiving treatment), heart failure (NYHA class 2 or higher at the time of enrollment), a left ventricular ejection fraction of 35% or less, or documented peripheral- artery disease); unsuitability for warfarin therapy due to inability to control international normalized ratio, increased risk for bleeding, patient refusal, or intermediate risk for stroke |
Exclusion criteria |
presence of conditions other than atrial fibrillation for which the patient required long-term anticoagulation, valvular disease requiring surgery, a serious bleeding event in the previous 6 months or a high risk of bleeding (e.g., active peptic ulcer disease, a platelet count of <100,000 per cubic millimeter or hemoglobin level of <10 g per deciliter, stroke within the previous 10 days, documented hemorrhagic tendencies, or blood dyscrasias), current alcohol or drug abuse or psychosocial issues, life expectancy of less than 1 year, severe renal insufficiency (a serum creatinine level of >2.5 mg per deciliter or a calculated creatinine clearance of <25 ml per minute), an alanine aminotransferase or aspartate aminotransferase level greater than 2 times the upper limit of the normal range or a total bilirubin more than 1.5 times the upper limit of the normal range, and allergy to aspirin. |
Baseline characteristics |
age(mean) |
70 years |
male(%) |
59% |
systolic blood pressure(mean) |
132 mmHg |
hypertension(%) |
86.5% |
diabete mellitus(%) |
19% |
prior stroke(%) |
13.5% |
prior TIA or stroke(%) |
14% |
left ventricular dysfunction(%) |
40% |
paroxysmal AF(%) |
27% |
heart failure(%) |
39% |
subgroup test |
a |
CHADS2 Score (mean) |
2.05 |
CHADS2 Score = 2 (%) |
36% (63.8% CHADS2>=2) |
CHADS2 Score = 3 (%) |
28% |
|
Method and design
Randomized effectives |
2808 / 2791 (studied vs. control) |
Design |
Parallel groups |
Blinding |
double blind |
Follow-up duration |
maximum 21 months |
Premature discontinuation |
Premature discontinuation for efficacy |
Number of centre |
522 |
Geographic area |
36 countries |
Hypothesis |
Superiority |
Primary endpoint |
stroke or systemic embolism |
Results
Endpoints and data reported in the trial's publication(s)
Endpoint |
Events (%) |
Relative Risk |
95% CI |
|
Studied treat. |
Control treat. |
Stroke or systemic embolism |
51 / 2808 (1,8%) |
113 / 2791 (4,0%) |
0,45 |
[0,32;0,62] |
|
Stroke, systemic embolism, or death |
143 / 2808 (5,1%) |
223 / 2791 (8,0%) |
0,64 |
[0,52;0,78] |
|
Stroke, systemic embolism, myocardial infarction or death from vascular cause |
132 / 2808 (4,7%) |
197 / 2791 (7,1%) |
0,67 |
[0,54;0,83] |
|
Stroke, systemic embolism, myocardial infarction, death from vascular cause, or major bleeding |
163 / 2808 (5,8%) |
220 / 2791 (7,9%) |
0,74 |
[0,61;0,90] |
|
Stroke |
49 / 2808 (1,7%) |
105 / 2791 (3,8%) |
0,46 |
[0,33;0,65] |
|
Ischemic Stroke |
35 / 2808 (1,2%) |
93 / 2791 (3,3%) |
0,37 |
[0,25;0,55] |
|
Hemorrhagic Stroke |
6 / 2808 (0,2%) |
9 / 2791 (0,3%) |
0,66 |
[0,24;1,86] |
|
Unspecified Stroke |
9 / 2808 (0,3%) |
4 / 2791 (0,1%) |
2,24 |
[0,69;7,25] |
|
Disabling or fatal Stroke |
31 / 2808 (1,1%) |
72 / 2791 (2,6%) |
0,43 |
[0,28;0,65] |
|
Systemic embolism |
2 / 2808 (0,1%) |
13 / 2791 (0,5%) |
0,15 |
[0,03;0,68] |
|
Myocardial infarction |
24 / 2808 (0,9%) |
28 / 2791 (1,0%) |
0,85 |
[0,50;1,47] |
|
Death From any cause |
111 / 2808 (4,0%) |
140 / 2791 (5,0%) |
0,79 |
[0,62;1,01] |
|
Death From vascular cause |
84 / 2808 (3,0%) |
96 / 2791 (3,4%) |
0,87 |
[0,65;1,16] |
|
Hospitalization for cardiovascular cause |
367 / 2808 (13,1%) |
455 / 2791 (16,3%) |
0,80 |
[0,71;0,91] |
|
Major Bleeding event |
44 / 2808 (1,6%) |
39 / 2791 (1,4%) |
1,12 |
[0,73;1,72] |
|
Intracranial Major Bleeding event |
11 / 2808 (0,4%) |
13 / 2791 (0,5%) |
0,84 |
[0,38;1,87] |
|
Subdural Major Bleeding event |
4 / 2808 (0,1%) |
2 / 2791 (0,1%) |
1,99 |
[0,36;10,84] |
|
Other intracranial bleeding, excluding hemorrhagic stroke and subdural |
1 / 2808 (0,0%) |
2 / 2791 (0,1%) |
0,50 |
[0,05;5,48] |
|
Extracranial or unclassified bleeding |
33 / 2808 (1,2%) |
27 / 2791 (1,0%) |
1,21 |
[0,73;2,01] |
|
Gastrointestinal bleeding |
12 / 2808 (0,4%) |
14 / 2791 (0,5%) |
0,85 |
[0,39;1,84] |
|
Non-gastrointestinal bleeding |
20 / 2808 (0,7%) |
13 / 2791 (0,5%) |
1,53 |
[0,76;3,07] |
|
Fatal bleeding |
4 / 2808 (0,1%) |
6 / 2791 (0,2%) |
0,66 |
[0,19;2,35] |
|
Clinically relevant nonmajor bleeding |
96 / 2808 (3,4%) |
84 / 2791 (3,0%) |
1,14 |
[0,85;1,52] |
|
Minor bleeding |
188 / 2808 (6,7%) |
153 / 2791 (5,5%) |
1,22 |
[0,99;1,50] |
|
Endpoints used by the meta-analysis and data retained for this trial
Endpoint
Studied treat. n/N
Control treat. n/N
Graph
RR [95% CI]
Coronary event
24 / 2808
28 / 2791
0,85 [0,50;1,47]
thrombo-embolic event (cerebral or systemic)
51 / 2808
113 / 2791
0,45 [0,32;0,62]
stroke (fatal and non fatal)
49 / 2808
105 / 2791
0,46 [0,33;0,65]
ischemic stroke
35 / 2808
93 / 2791
0,37 [0,25;0,55]
myocardial infarction (fatal and non fatal)
24 / 2808
28 / 2791
0,85 [0,50;1,47]
All cause death
111 / 2808
140 / 2791
0,79 [0,62;1,01]
Major bleeding
44 / 2808
39 / 2791
1,12 [0,73;1,72]
Minor bleeding
188 / 2808
153 / 2791
1,22 [0,99;1,50]
Haemmorhagic stroke
6 / 2808
9 / 2791
0,66 [0,24;1,86]
Fatal bleeding
4 / 2808
6 / 2791
classic
0,66 [0,19;2,35]
Gastrointestinal major bleeding
12 / 2808
14 / 2791
0,85 [0,39;1,84]
Cardiovascular death
84 / 2808
96 / 2791
0,87 [0,65;1,16]
intracranial hemorrhage
11 / 2808
13 / 2791
0,84 [0,38;1,87]
0
2
1.0
Relative risks
|
Endpoint |
Events (%) |
Relative Risk |
95% CI |
Endpoint definition in the trial |
Ref |
Studied treat. |
Control treat. |
Coronary event
|
24 / 2808 (0,9%) |
28 / 2791 (1,0%) |
0,85 |
[0,50;1,47] |
|
16949 |
thrombo-embolic event (cerebral or systemic)
|
51 / 2808 (1,8%) |
113 / 2791 (4,0%) |
0,45 |
[0,32;0,62] |
Stroke or systemic embolism |
|
stroke (fatal and non fatal)
|
49 / 2808 (1,7%) |
105 / 2791 (3,8%) |
0,46 |
[0,33;0,65] |
Stroke |
|
ischemic stroke
|
35 / 2808 (1,2%) |
93 / 2791 (3,3%) |
0,37 |
[0,25;0,55] |
Ischemic Stroke |
|
myocardial infarction (fatal and non fatal)
|
24 / 2808 (0,9%) |
28 / 2791 (1,0%) |
0,85 |
[0,50;1,47] |
Myocardial infarction |
|
All cause death
|
111 / 2808 (4,0%) |
140 / 2791 (5,0%) |
0,79 |
[0,62;1,01] |
Death From any cause |
|
Major bleeding
|
44 / 2808 (1,6%) |
39 / 2791 (1,4%) |
1,12 |
[0,73;1,72] |
Major Bleeding event |
|
Minor bleeding
|
188 / 2808 (6,7%) |
153 / 2791 (5,5%) |
1,22 |
[0,99;1,50] |
Minor bleeding |
|
Haemmorhagic stroke
|
6 / 2808 (0,2%) |
9 / 2791 (0,3%) |
0,66 |
[0,24;1,86] |
Hemorrhagic Stroke |
|
Fatal bleeding
|
4 / 2808 (0,1%) |
6 / 2791 (0,2%) |
0,66 |
[0,19;2,35] |
Fatal bleeding |
|
Gastrointestinal major bleeding
|
12 / 2808 (0,4%) |
14 / 2791 (0,5%) |
0,85 |
[0,39;1,84] |
Gastrointestinal bleeding |
|
Cardiovascular death
|
84 / 2808 (3,0%) |
96 / 2791 (3,4%) |
0,87 |
[0,65;1,16] |
Death From vascular cause |
|
intracranial hemorrhage
|
11 / 2808 (0,4%) |
13 / 2791 (0,5%) |
0,84 |
[0,38;1,87] |
Intracranial Major Bleeding event |
|
The primary endpoint (if exists) appears in blod characters
|
Reference(s) used for data extraction:
16949: Mak KHCoronary and mortality risk of novel oral antithrombotic agents: a meta-analysis of large randomised trials.BMJ Open 2012;2:
|
Endpoint |
studied treat. |
control treat. |
mean diff |
Absolute risk reduction (for a follow-up of maximum 21 months)
|
Endpoint |
Events rate |
Absolute risk reduction (ARR) |
Studied treat. |
Control treat. |
Coronary event |
8,55‰ |
1,00% |
-0,15%
|
thrombo-embolic event (cerebral or systemic) |
1,82% |
4,05% |
-2,23%
|
stroke (fatal and non fatal) |
1,75% |
3,76% |
-2,02%
|
ischemic stroke |
1,25% |
3,33% |
-2,09%
|
myocardial infarction (fatal and non fatal) |
8,55‰ |
1,00% |
-0,15%
|
All cause death |
3,95% |
5,02% |
-1,06%
|
Major bleeding |
1,57% |
1,40% |
0,17%
|
Minor bleeding |
6,70% |
5,48% |
1,2%
|
Haemmorhagic stroke |
2,14‰ |
3,22‰ |
-0,11%
|
Fatal bleeding |
1,42‰ |
2,15‰ |
-0,07%
|
Gastrointestinal major bleeding |
4,27‰ |
5,02‰ |
-0,07%
|
Cardiovascular death |
2,99% |
3,44% |
-0,45%
|
intracranial hemorrhage |
3,92‰ |
4,66‰ |
-0,07%
|
Meta-analysis of all similar trials:
antithrombotics in atrial fibrillation for patients ineligible for warfarin
antithrombotics in atrial fibrillation for primary prevention of thromboembolic events
direct factor Xa inhibitors in atrial fibrillation for all type of patients
Reference(s)
TrialResults-center ID |
TRC10340
|
Trials register # |
NCT00496769
|
-
Eikelboom JW, O'Donnell M, Yusuf S, Diaz R, Flaker G, Hart R, Hohnloser S, Joyner C, Lawrence J, Pais P, Pogue J, Synhorst D, Connolly SJ.
Rationale and design of AVERROES: apixaban versus acetylsalicylic acid to prevent stroke in atrial fibrillation patients who have failed or are unsuitable for vitamin K antagonist treatment..
Am Heart J 2010;159:348-353.e1
- 10.1016/j.ahj.2009.08.026
Pubmed
|
Hubmed
| Fulltext
-
Connolly SJ, Eikelboom J, Joyner C, Diener HC, Hart R, Golitsyn S, Flaker G, Avezum A, Hohnloser SH, Diaz R, Talajic M, Zhu J, Pais P, Budaj A, Parkhomenko A, Jansky P, Commerford P, Tan RS, Sim KH, Lewis BS, Van Mieghem W, Lip GY, Kim JH, Lanas-Zanetti F.
Apixaban in Patients with Atrial Fibrillation..
N Engl J Med 2011 Feb 10;:
- 10.1056/NEJMoa1007432
Pubmed
|
Hubmed
| Fulltext
|